Hannaford Associates Ltd
Menu
  • What we think
  • Consultancy and Training
  • Who we are
  • Contact
  • What we think
  • Consultancy and Training
  • Who we are
  • Contact

Striking conceptual similarities between the Patisserie Valerie scandal and Enron


By admin | October 22, 2018 | Category The Big Picture, Training offered by Hannaford Associates

There are striking similarities between the Patisserie Valerie scandal and Enron because they both have entailed the concealment of debt away from the firm’s balance sheet.

In each case the finance director has initially been vilified but a striking similarity is the cashing in of equity-related personal benefits by senior connected players in both events. In 2001 Geoffrey Skilling, the Enron chief executive resigned his position and sold somewhere in the area of $60 million worth of stock.  Both the PV finance director and chief executive, Chris Marsh and Paul May respectively cashed in options in February this year on the quoted equity of the firm for a total amount of about £2.9 million pre tax. Smaller beer but the  comparison is clear.

Neither transaction would have been possible had the public information about either firm been the truth. Both transactions were based on verified public but misleading information that formed material basis for equity value of the respective firms.

Where transactions have taken place to enrich those that have made or authorised untruthful statements there must be a strong case for accusations of fraud. I have no doubt that regulators will pull the firm limb from limb as well as conducting very close scrutiny on the relationship with the auditors, Grant Thornton who will have to be able to demonstrate that they too were misled and that they were throuough enough in their dealings with the firm. The FCA is inclined to concentrate on insider trading and market abuse which is right but surely far more emphasis needs to be deployed in the area of misleading the market and investors in this way where the consequences are the failure of an entire firm.

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recent Posts


  • The Tesco/SFO fiasco also explains the dramatic fall in Financial Conduct Authority fines
  • If we do have another referendum, will it be on an “advisory” basis?
  • Post Brexit, should legitimate client entertainment continue to be an “illegal inducement” for FCA regulated firms?
  • Patisserie Valerie. When is the selective briefing of an institutional investor legitimate?
  • Blackrock, have decided to stay in London – skyscrapers in Calais?
  • Striking conceptual similarities between the Patisserie Valerie scandal and Enron
  • The EU cannot offer an equivalent of the clearing for the processing of trillions of dollars worth of derivative contracts
  • How to spot sociopathic/NPD behaviour and misconduct within your organisation
  • Payment for flow – should be illegal as it’s not in a Client’s interest
  • Dansk Bank failed to identify the beneficial owners of undesirable financial vehicles…

Pages


  • Consulting and Training
  • Contact
  • Stephen Cooper CV
  • What we think
  • Who we are

Tag Cloud


Categories


  • Services offered by Hannaford Associates
  • The benefits of Workflow
  • The Big Picture
  • Training offered by Hannaford Associates
  • Uncategorized

Recent Posts

  • The Tesco/SFO fiasco also explains the dramatic fall in Financial Conduct Authority fines
  • If we do have another referendum, will it be on an “advisory” basis?
  • Post Brexit, should legitimate client entertainment continue to be an “illegal inducement” for FCA regulated firms?
  • Patisserie Valerie. When is the selective briefing of an institutional investor legitimate?
  • Blackrock, have decided to stay in London – skyscrapers in Calais?
  • Striking conceptual similarities between the Patisserie Valerie scandal and Enron
  • The EU cannot offer an equivalent of the clearing for the processing of trillions of dollars worth of derivative contracts
  • How to spot sociopathic/NPD behaviour and misconduct within your organisation
  • Payment for flow – should be illegal as it’s not in a Client’s interest
  • Dansk Bank failed to identify the beneficial owners of undesirable financial vehicles…

Tag Cloud

Pages

  • Consulting and Training
  • Contact
  • Stephen Cooper CV
  • What we think
  • Who we are

Categories

  • Services offered by Hannaford Associates
  • The benefits of Workflow
  • The Big Picture
  • Training offered by Hannaford Associates
  • Uncategorized

Copyright © 2015 Hanford Associates Ltd

Theme created by PWT. Powered by WordPress.org